Jersey Mike’s Secret Menu With Prices For 2026
Worth saying upfront: Jersey Mike’s doesn’t operate an official, corporate-sanctioned secret menu the way a rumor might suggest. What actually exists is a collection of customer-invented and staff-tested off-menu builds — combinations of ingredients already on the regular menu, reassembled in ways that never made it onto the overhead board — that have spread through word of mouth and social media until they developed something close to a following of their own.
A lot of the credit for keeping this alive goes to employees and area managers who’ve shared these builds online, including a Jersey Mike’s manager known online as “That Crazy Sub Guy,” whose social accounts have become something of an unofficial reference point for which off-menu combinations are actually worth ordering. Because none of this is standardized corporate policy, availability, ingredient access, and whether a given cashier even recognizes a fan nickname can all vary from one location to the next.
This guide walks through the most talked-about off-menu builds, how to actually describe them at the counter so you get what you’re picturing, and roughly what they’ll cost given they’re built from existing menu components rather than priced separately.
Jersey Mike’s Secret Menu With Prices
Because these builds use ingredients from the regular menu rather than being separately priced items, cost generally tracks whatever base sandwich you’re modifying plus any extra meat or premium add-ons, typically landing $1 to $4 above a standard Regular sub. None of these are guaranteed to work at every location, and staff may need the ingredient breakdown rather than a nickname to build them correctly.
The Number 99
The Number 99 is arguably the most famous and most consistently documented off-menu build, combining the Big Kahuna Cheese Steak (steak, onions, peppers, mushrooms, jalapeños, and extra cheese) with a layer of Chipotle Mayo borrowed from the Chipotle Cheese Steak. The name comes from adding the numbers of the two sandwiches it’s based on — 56 and 43 — together, which is a detail regulars sometimes use to explain the request if a cashier looks confused.
Because this build starts from two already-loaded hot subs, it lands on the richer, spicier end of the menu, and it’s generally recommended for guests who already enjoy the Big Kahuna and want to push the flavor further rather than as a first introduction to Jersey Mike’s hot subs. Ordering it is straightforward: ask for a Big Kahuna Cheese Steak with Chipotle Mayo added, rather than expecting a cashier to recognize “the 99” by name alone, since not every location uses that nickname internally.
Some locations have reportedly added a shortcut button for this exact combination given how often it’s requested, though this isn’t guaranteed everywhere, so describing the actual ingredients is the more reliable approach regardless of location.
| Item | How To Order It | Estimated Price |
|---|---|---|
| The Number 99 | Big Kahuna Cheese Steak + Chipotle Mayo | $13.50–$15.00 |
Surf ‘n Turf
Surf ‘n Turf takes the #9 Club Supreme and adds seafood into the mix, giving guests a genuine land-and-sea combination in sandwich form rather than the more typical single-protein build most subs stick to. This is one of the more polarizing off-menu items — the roast beef and tuna combination sounds unusual on paper, and reactions to it tend to run strongly in one direction or the other rather than landing in the middle.
Because this build combines two distinct protein types that aren’t normally paired on the standard menu, it’s worth confirming your specific location actually has both roast beef and tuna in stock and is willing to combine them, since this is a less commonly requested combination than something like the Number 99. Adding your own vegetables on top is optional, and some guests prefer to keep it simple with just the two proteins and mayo to let the flavor combination stand on its own.
| Item | How To Order It | Estimated Price |
|---|---|---|
| Surf ‘n Turf | #9 Club Supreme, add tuna | $12.50–$14.50 |
The Beef Bacon Ranch
The Beef Bacon Ranch is a simple swap on an existing menu item rather than a complicated new build — take the #26 Bacon Ranch Chicken Cheese Steak and substitute beef for chicken. Because hot subs already taste noticeably different depending on protein, this swap changes the character of the sandwich more than the small size of the modification might suggest, turning a chicken-forward lunch sub into something that feels closer to a dinner order.
This is one of the easier off-menu requests to make successfully, since it’s a straightforward ingredient substitution rather than a combination of two separate sandwiches, and most staff can execute it without needing much explanation beyond “make the 26 with beef instead of chicken.”
| Item | How To Order It | Estimated Price |
|---|---|---|
| Beef Bacon Ranch | #26 Bacon Ranch Cheese Steak, beef instead of chicken | $12.00–$13.50 |
Grilled Chicken Ranch Wrap
The Grilled Chicken Ranch Wrap takes a standard wrap format and customizes it toward a specific, well-documented flavor combination: grilled chicken with lettuce, tomato, onion, and ranch, wrapped in a grilled tortilla rather than served cold. Some locations reportedly prepare this specifically as a “hot wrap” when requested, giving it a warmer, more toasted texture than a standard cold wrap.
Because this build stays close to ingredients already commonly paired together elsewhere on the menu, it tends to be one of the more reliably executed off-menu requests across different locations, without requiring an unusual protein combination or a specific nickname to be understood.
| Item | How To Order It | Estimated Price |
|---|---|---|
| Grilled Chicken Ranch Wrap (hot) | Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, onion, ranch, in a grilled tortilla | $10.50–$12.00 |
The “Everything” Giant
The “Everything” Giant is less a specific named sandwich and more a customer-driven approach to maximizing a Giant sub order: ask for a Giant with every cold meat available layered together rather than picking a single numbered combination. Because this uses significantly more meat than any standard menu item, staff will typically price it at a premium above a regular Giant sub rather than charging standard pricing.
This build is specifically suited to sharing across a larger group rather than a single-person meal, given both the size and the sheer quantity of protein involved, and it’s worth confirming pricing with your specific location before ordering since the premium charge isn’t standardized the way regular menu pricing is.
| Item | How To Order It | Estimated Price |
|---|---|---|
| The “Everything” Giant | Giant sub, every cold meat available | $22.00–$28.00 (premium pricing) |
Tips For Ordering Off The Jersey Mike’s Secret Menu
Because none of these builds are official menu items, describing the actual ingredients rather than relying on a fan nickname is the most reliable way to get what you’re picturing, especially at a location where staff haven’t encountered the specific request before. If a cashier looks unsure, breaking the order down into the base sandwich number plus the specific modification — like “a #56 Big Kahuna with chipotle mayo added” — tends to work better than just saying “the 99.”
Availability also depends on what a given location actually has in stock, so a build that worked at one Jersey Mike’s, like the tuna-and-roast-beef Surf ‘n Turf, might need substitution or simply isn’t possible at a store that’s out of one of the components that day. Treat these as starting points for your own customization rather than guaranteed, universally recognized orders, since the appeal of a fan-built menu is really in the flexibility to build your own version anyway.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Jersey Mike’s Have An Official Secret Menu?
No, Jersey Mike’s does not formally advertise or operate a corporate secret menu — these are customer-invented and staff-shared off-menu combinations built from existing ingredients.
What Is The Number 99 At Jersey Mike’s?
The Number 99 combines the Big Kahuna Cheese Steak with Chipotle Mayo from the Chipotle Cheese Steak, and its name comes from adding the two base sandwich numbers, 56 and 43, together.
How Do You Order A Secret Menu Item At Jersey Mike’s?
Describing the actual ingredients or base sandwich plus modification — rather than relying on a fan nickname — is the most reliable way to get what you want, since not every location recognizes the same names.
Is The Jersey Mike’s Secret Menu The Same At Every Location?
No, availability depends on what ingredients a specific location has in stock and whether staff are familiar with the particular off-menu request, so results can vary store to store.
Who Popularized The Jersey Mike’s Secret Menu?
Much of the visibility comes from customers and employees sharing combinations on social media, including a Jersey Mike’s manager known online as “That Crazy Sub Guy.”
Does Ordering An Off-Menu Item Cost More At Jersey Mike’s?
Sometimes — builds that add extra meat or combine two sandwiches, like The “Everything” Giant, are generally priced at a premium above the standard menu item they’re based on.
Final Word
The Jersey Mike’s “secret menu” isn’t really a hidden menu at all — it’s a set of fan-built combinations assembled from ingredients the chain already stocks, kept alive through word of mouth and social media rather than any official rollout. Once you understand that, ordering one becomes less about knowing a password and more about clearly describing what you want.
The Number 99 remains the most consistently documented and widely recognized build, while others, like the Surf ‘n Turf, are more of a gamble depending on your local store’s stock and staff familiarity. Because none of this is standardized, the safest approach is always to describe the base sandwich and modification rather than assuming a nickname will be understood.
If a build doesn’t work out exactly as pictured, that’s really the nature of an unofficial menu — treat it as a jumping-off point for your own customization rather than a guaranteed order every time.
